Today was School Board day in Pearland, and around two hundred Pearlanders showed up. I was travelling and my flight arrived at IAH at 5:08 p.m. (scheduled: 4:50 p.m.) The Board meeting had already started as I was driving on Beltway 8 to get there. My phone rings. Mrs. Anti-Corruption was nearly in tears as she told me that Board President Tom Allen had resigned, citing health issues. I have always admired Mr. Allen and even wrote something to that effect at the old place. I'll have to dig that up.
If it wasn't bad enough that the popular Mr. Allen resigned, there was another controversy. It was this controversy that caused the full house at the School Board meeting. Another Pearland ISD Board Member, Suzy Roberts, has raised the ire of the Pearland faithful by taking a position that many have interpreted as anti-Christian. Here is an e-mail forwarded and re-forwarded to nearly every Pearland resident:
Dear Ms. XXXX,
Thank you for your thoughtful request for my position. In this storm of misrepresentation it is quite refreshing, and sadly, rare.
I never stated that half of Pearland wants to end prayer. I voiced my concern that since, according to www.arda.com , only 50.3% of North Brazoria County residents claim Christianity as their religion, perhaps we should review the boards' practices regarding prayer and take into consideration how others might feel. I also asked what exactly was legal regarding prayer these days. I had no idea it would turn into such a firestorm.
I am listed next to the item "Pledge and Prayer" because it is my turn to lead. This item is on every agenda. On the November agenda, we expect to hear the lawyer tell us the current state of the law.
Personally, I was not raised to pray in public. My father was Catholic and my mother was Episcopalian and I was taught to pray in church or privately, on my knees. As to the Pledge of Allegiance, I would never question that and never have. My own father's death was ruled related to injuries he suffered in WWII and we received Veteran's Benefits. My only maternal uncle was killed in WWII and my grandfather was a Colonel on Eisenhower's staff in London. I can trace my family to signers of the Declaration of Independence and am eligible for the DAR (Daughters of the American Revolution) many times over. I have never bothered to petition for membership because my loyalty and patriotism have never before been questioned. Perhaps I should reconsider.
One other thing I have always taken to heart and tried to lead my life by is Matthew 7:12, "Whatever you want men to do to you, do also to them."
I really regret that this has turned into such a firestorm. There is no way to defend myself against such a grapevine of innacuracy [sic].
Thank you for asking for my input.
Sincerely,
Suzy Roberts
----- Original Message -----
From: XXXXXXX XXXXX
To: XXXXXXXXX@earthlink.net
Sent: 10/8/2007 2:35:55 PM
Subject: Please clarify your position
Ms. Roberts,
Im sure that youve received many emails by now from concerned parents about the issue of Prayer. Can you please clarify, for me, your position on prayer in school and other functions regarding the school board. If you are seriously considering abandoning prayer in our schools, I would ask you to re-consider. I support prayer and the pledge in our schools, games, board meetings and any other function. I am a parent and a life long citizen of Pearland as are my parents and siblings and their children. I plan on staying in Pearland and continuing to raise my two daughters here and FULLY support them saying a prayer and the pledge to the United States and Texas in school.
Sincerely,
XXXXXXX XXXXX
[For the record, both of my parents were raised Baptist, though I am unchurched now. My father was never in the military. My only maternal uncle was never in the military. My grandfather was never in the military. I was never in the military. I can trace my family to Kosciusko, Mississippi where some are pillars of the community and others are gardern-variety ne'er-do-wells. I doubt I'm eligible for SAR (Sons of the American Revolution) or Mensa. I have no desire to join either group. No one has ever questioned my patriotism, but I've never seen any evidence that anyone has ever questioned Ms. Roberts' patriotism, either. I have no clue why any of this is relevant.]
In the end, Ms. Roberts did offer an invocation. Prior to the invocation, she instructed the audience to "adopt your form of prayer and worship." Whatever that means.
Pearland ISD has a policy limiting public comments to three minutes. This policy has been put in place to prevent long-winded speakers from monopolizing the Board Meeting. A large number (it would be interesting to know how many) of Pearland residents arrived early and signed in for an opportunity to speak during public comments. After Mr. Allen's announcement that he was resigning, and his closing in prayer, it was time for public comments. After a five minute recess and tearful good-byes to Mr. Allen, Board Member Florida Dotson announced that public comments regarding prayer be limited due to the issue's popularity. Ms. Dotson stated that only four people would be permitted to speak on the issue of prayer in school. Ms. Dotson suggested that those interested in speaking step outside to choose the four that the Pearland ISD School Board would allow to speak. A Pearland resident in the public seating area suggested in frustration that the first four people who signed up be allowed to speak. And so it was.
On a personal level, I support everything in the
First Amendment to the US Constitution. I support the freedom of religion, the ability to petition government for the redress of grievances, the freedom of press, the freedom of assembly and the freedom of speech. I would have liked to see all of these freedoms on display at the Pearland ISD Board Meeting. Unfortunately, the freedom of a lot people to petition government for the redress of grievances through speech was sharply curtailed at tonight's meeting.
Issues at Pearland ISD are tearing this community apart. Or maybe they are bringing the community together. If all those Christians knew some of the things I do about a program soon to be implemented across Pearland ISD, the level of community involvement would increase even further. It is hard for me to decide what the proper course of action is.
==
Here are some of Mr. Allen's statements after he announced his resignation:
My greatest concern as I leave this position is not for the challenges you face from without, but rather those that come from within. I believe that you are being challenged to compromise, to elevate tolerance above morality and the values of this community. I want to encourage this Board to be intolerant, to not place political correctness and playing nice in public above courage and conviction. [Applause] Do not think that to get God out and condoms in would in any way make this a better district. [Applause]
I know you're on television now, but I encourage you, Board, to resist the temptation to smile and placate, but rather to say "Shut up" when it is called for. To the community, I would say if any Member of this Board fails to represent you and the majority of this community, please make it very, very clear to them that they will not be tolerated and they will not be invited back to take their seat. [Applause] To the Superintendent and staff, I would like to say you are some of the finest folks that I have had the opportunity to serve alongside. I only hope that I have adequately supported you and made your job an easier one. Continue to put our kids first. I am proud to have been part of it.
When the inevitable questions arise about whether we value academics or athletics or arts, please say, "In Pearland, we value excellence." We do it all, but we do it all with excellence.
Click on the Carleston tag to see my other posts on Pearland ISD.